Blog

Why are you personalizing everything except the stuff that actually makes money?

Written by Igor Pauletič | 9/4/2025

These days, marketing has one mantra: personalization. Personalized content. Personalized experiences. Personalized customer journeys. All good. But when it comes to pricing — suddenly, all that bragging about personalization goes silent. Why? Especially when dynamic pricing is the biggest lever you’ve got for boosting your margins. The answer’s simple. Actually, twofold. 


First is because real personalization in pricing takes real data. Second: is because you need a platform that lets you orchestrate your direct communication — across all channels — in real time. Emails, SMS, your webshop, your app, ads, mobile wallets, Viber, WhatsApp… 

Only then can you actually be consistent when showing a price that changes based on the person seeing it. 

But let’s be honest: you’re not doing that if you’re sending emails through Klaviyo or Mailchimp, pushing SMS campaigns manually from some local tool, and updating webshop prices once a day from your ERP.  There’s just no way to automate personalized pricing at scale if your whole stack is glued together like that. 

Loyalty is expensive. And it rarely pays. 

Here’s the question no one in marketing really dares to ask: Why should we personalize prices in the first place? The answer? 
Because the biggest profit lies in the one area we still pretend to keep “fair.” We love to believe we treat customers equally. That we’re fair. 


But if you’re being honest: you make the most money off your most loyal customers. The quiet ones. The ones who don’t ask questions, don’t compare prices — they just buy. Subscription businesses love these customers. Sleeping beauties, just quietly paying. Meanwhile, the ones who barely know us — or are already halfway out the door — get the best deals. Discounts. Bonuses. Incentives. All just to hook them or keep them a bit longer. 

Personally? I hate those ads from banks or internet providers offering half-price to new customers — while I get zero after 15 years of loyalty. That’s the unspoken paradox of pricing personalization: The more loyal you are, the less you get. The more flaky you are, the more we throw at you. 

Makes no sense, right? Actually… it does. But it could be done way more subtly. With dynamic, personalized pricing — across direct channels. 

Clear wins where dynamic pricing drives real profit 

 

What is the difference

Aspect 

Static Pricing 

Dynamic Pricing 

Who sets the price 

Marketing — same for everyone 

Algorithm — adjusts in real time 

Is it personalized? 

Nope — one price fits all 

Yep — everyone sees their own 

Channel consistency 

Often out of sync 

Fully aligned, across all touchpoints 

Margin control 

Limited 

High — tuned to context 

Perceived fairness 

Looks “fair” — everyone gets the same 

Feels exclusive — everyone gets their price 

Business impact 

Easy to manage, poor results 

Harder to pull off, but far more profitable 

How it works — without chaos or guesswork 

If you want pricing that adapts to customer context, you need a few things locked in: 

  • Clear rules (If X, then Y) 
  • A unified platform that runs in real time 
  • Connected channels (email, app, POS, web) 

It’s not magic. It’s not some AI black box. It’s infrastructure. And most importantly: you stay in control, you set the limits. Who, when, why, how much. The platform just makes it happen — fast, consistent, traceable. That’s how you stop personalizing blindly — and start doing it based on actual data. 

If you’re already personalizing content — why not pricing? 

Dynamic pricing isn’t manipulation. It’s just smart business. If you can tailor your messaging, your content, your channel and timing — why not the price? It’s not trickery. It’s just using context in a way that makes sense — to offer the right price to the right person at the right time. 

And if you’re not doing it yet, someone else probably is. Maybe already right now. Still not convinced? At least calculate how much your unnecessary discounts are costing you each year. Half that lost revenue could already fund a system that stops the bleeding. Pretty sure about that. 

Need help running the numbers? My team’s happy to jump in.

📩 igor.pauletic@frodx.com